We have become remarkably good at measuring the environmental performance of buildings. But how do we bring the same discipline to understanding their impact on people?
Changing Tomorrow | Season 3, Bonus Episode 2
In this episode of Changing Tomorrow, Kimberly Lewis and Gayathri Unnikrishnan discuss People Positive: Building the Human Dimension of Sustainability and explore how organizations can make human impact part of everyday decisions.
Listen to the conversation:
Read the book: People Positive
Over the past few decades, the built environment has made considerable progress in understanding and measuring environmental performance. We have developed increasingly sophisticated methods for calculating energy consumption, embodied carbon, operational emissions, and resource efficiency. These metrics now inform how buildings are designed, financed, constructed, and operated. Although the systems are far from perfect, they have helped translate environmental concerns into something organizations can evaluate, manage, and act upon.
Yet there is an interesting gap in this progress. While we can calculate the carbon footprint of a flooring product or model a building's energy consumption decades into the future, we are less consistent about understanding what those same decisions mean for the people who manufacture, install, clean, maintain, and occupy our buildings. Their experiences and working conditions are often considered separately from the performance of the building itself, even though they are directly influenced by how it is designed and operated.
This is a question Kimberly Lewis and I explored in a recent conversation on Changing Tomorrow, drawing on some of the ideas in my book, People Positive. How do we bring human impact into the systems we already use to make decisions, particularly when budgets, deadlines, and competing priorities make those decisions difficult?
The Reality in the Project Room
Consider a hypothetical scenario that will be familiar to anyone who has worked on a building project. Construction is running behind schedule, material costs have increased, and the team is looking for ways to bring the project back within budget. During a design coordination meeting, someone proposes replacing the originally specified flooring with a less expensive alternative. The replacement meets the immediate technical requirements, is available within the project timeline, and offers a meaningful cost saving. From the perspective of the information being reviewed in that meeting, the substitution appears reasonable.
But a material change can have implications beyond its purchase price and stated performance. Depending on the products involved, the replacement flooring might require a different adhesive or installation process, changing the occupational exposures or working conditions of the installation crew. It may also require more intensive cleaning or maintenance, introducing additional costs and potential chemical exposures for facilities personnel over the life of the building. The change could affect indoor air quality for occupants as well. None of these outcomes is inevitable, and some alternatives may actually improve conditions. The important point is that these consequences need to be understood and considered alongside cost, schedule, and technical performance.
The people who experience these downstream effects are unlikely to be present when the substitution is approved. Installers, custodians, maintenance workers, and future occupants may have little opportunity to influence a decision that shapes their working conditions or daily experiences for years. Meanwhile, the team making the decision may have no practical way of accessing that information, particularly when the project's existing documentation does not require it.
This illustrates one of the central ideas in People Positive: every decision creates benefits, burdens, and change for someone. Understanding those consequences is an important part of making better decisions, but it requires us to look beyond the people and performance indicators immediately visible in the project room.
Giving Human Impact a Place in the Process
When social sustainability commitments disappear during project delivery, we often attribute the outcome to a lack of leadership or organizational will. Those factors certainly matter, but experience has taught me that the explanation is frequently more complicated. Many of the people involved in designing and delivering buildings genuinely care about their work and its consequences. They are also managing demanding schedules, divided responsibilities, incomplete information, and budgets that leave little room for experimentation. Under those conditions, decisions tend to be guided by the requirements and information already embedded in established workflows.
Environmental certifications provide an instructive example of how this can change. One reason certification systems have influenced building practices is that they translated broad environmental ambitions into specific requirements, documentation processes, and responsibilities that could be carried across project phases. An energy target or material requirement became something that architects, contractors, consultants, and building owners could track and verify. The process was not always straightforward, but it gave environmental objectives a more durable place in project delivery.
There is an opportunity to apply similar discipline to human outcomes without creating an entirely new layer of administration. In many cases, the necessary infrastructure already exists in procurement systems, design review procedures, project management tools, construction documentation, and operational planning. What is missing is the information about people, along with clear responsibilities for considering that information when decisions are made.
The objective is to make human impact part of ordinary business practice, rather than something addressed primarily through a sustainability report or an aspirational statement. That requires organizations to understand which decisions have meaningful consequences for people, identify the evidence needed to evaluate those consequences, and establish who is responsible for acting on what they learn.
Bringing People Into Everyday Decisions
One practical place to begin is with material substitutions and value engineering. When project teams review alternatives, they can consider whether a proposed change affects installation methods, worker safety, maintenance requirements, or occupant health. This does not mean every substitution requires an extensive social impact assessment. It means identifying the relevant questions early enough to investigate meaningful risks and trade-offs before a decision becomes difficult to reverse.
Procurement offers another opportunity. Manufacturers and suppliers are increasingly familiar with requests for environmental product declarations, material ingredient information, and carbon data. Questions about labor conditions, worker protections, and supply chain visibility can become part of these existing conversations. Some manufacturers will have established systems for answering them, while others may have significant gaps in their knowledge. Recording those gaps, identifying priorities, and following up over time can help create clearer expectations and encourage better practices throughout the supply chain.
The knowledge of people working in and around buildings is equally valuable. Facilities teams understand which materials are difficult to maintain, which spaces create operational challenges, and how design decisions perform under everyday conditions. Installers understand the practical realities of construction methods and site safety. Engaging these workers as knowledgeable contributors, respecting their time, and ensuring that their feedback can influence decisions can reveal issues that are difficult to identify through drawings, specifications, or performance models alone.
Finally, organizations need to connect their commitments to the resources and responsibilities required to deliver them. A goal related to worker health, community well-being, or equitable access is more likely to survive changes in personnel, budgets, and schedules when someone is accountable for its implementation. Depending on the goal, this might require dedicated funding, a procurement requirement, a documented project decision, or a performance measure that can be reviewed over time. The specific mechanism matters less than ensuring that the commitment has a clear and practical place within the organization's existing processes.
The Work Ahead
Decarbonization remains an essential priority for the built environment, and the progress made in environmental measurement has given the industry valuable tools for addressing it. But environmental performance alone cannot provide a complete picture of sustainability. A highly efficient building may still be connected to poor working conditions, harmful exposures, or decisions that place disproportionate burdens on people with little influence over the process.
Recognizing these connections does not mean that every decision will produce an obvious answer. There will continue to be trade-offs between cost, availability, environmental performance, human health, and other project priorities. The purpose of bringing human impact into the conversation is to make those trade-offs more visible, so that the people making decisions have a fuller understanding of their consequences.
We have already demonstrated that complex sustainability considerations can become part of routine organizational practice when they are supported by evidence, clear responsibilities, and appropriate systems. Applying that experience to social sustainability is an opportunity to build on what the industry has learned, rather than start again.
Ultimately, our buildings, products, and communities are shaped by thousands of decisions made by people working within larger systems. We may not be able to change every aspect of those systems at once, but we can change what we pay attention to, what information we ask for, and how we account for the consequences of our choices. That is where the work of becoming People Positive begins.
This article draws on a conversation between Kimberly Lewis and Gayathri Unnikrishnan on Changing Tomorrow about the ideas behind People Positive and the practical work of integrating human impact into everyday organizational decisions.
Listen to the full episode:
Explore the book: People Positive: Building the Human Dimension of Sustainability