Changing Tomorrow Season 3 Bonus Episode: What Park Avenue Doormen Can Teach Us About Building Design
This article is a recap of our conversation with Stephen Bruno, diving into the frontline realities of building operations, back-of-house spatial design, and the human trust that holds facilities together.
🎧 Stream the full conversation:
📘 Read the book: Get your copy of People Positive by Gayathri Unnikrishnan here
What the people who operate our buildings can teach us about design, performance, and the human experience of place.
Changing Tomorrow | Season 3, Bonus Episode
The performance of a building is typically evaluated through a combination of financial returns, environmental metrics, and occupant experience. Owners invest in attractive public spaces, efficient building systems, and amenities that improve the experience of residents and tenants. Yet the people responsible for keeping these environments functioning often experience a very different side of the same building, one that receives considerably less attention during design and operational planning.
Consider the contrast between a carefully designed residential lobby and the spaces provided for the people who work there. A building may have generous circulation areas, sophisticated security systems, and comfortable lounges for residents, while its staff facilities combine lockers, dining areas, and restrooms in a single room. Employees may be expected to maintain formal dress codes during periods of extreme heat, even when environmental conditions make those requirements uncomfortable. These arrangements are not necessarily the result of deliberate disregard. They can emerge from longstanding operational conventions, competing demands for space, and decisions made without fully understanding how employees experience the building throughout their working day.
These questions came into focus in a recent episode of Changing Tomorrow with Stephen Bruno, author of Building Material: The Memoir of a Park Avenue Doorman. Having spent more than 15 years working in Manhattan residential real estate, Stephen brings a perspective shaped by his daily experience of buildings, his relationships with the people who inhabit them, and his thoughtful observations about work, class, and human connection. His insights offer an opportunity to consider aspects of building performance that rarely find their way into architectural drawings or operational assessments.
The distinction matters because building performance extends beyond the experience of the people who own or occupy a property. It is also shaped by the conditions under which people clean, secure, maintain, and operate it. Their working environments influence health, comfort, safety, and the ability to perform their responsibilities effectively. Understanding those conditions offers a more complete picture of how well a building serves the people connected to it.
The Spaces Behind the Spaces
Architectural programming involves allocating space among many competing requirements, from rentable floor area and circulation to mechanical systems and shared amenities. Staff facilities are part of that equation, but they can be treated primarily as functional necessities rather than environments that deserve the same consideration given to occupant-facing spaces.
The consequences can be surprisingly ordinary. A break room located beside noisy mechanical equipment may offer little opportunity for genuine rest. Inadequate storage can make daily routines more difficult. A poorly ventilated changing area or a lack of accessible seating can affect employees who spend long hours on their feet. Individually, these conditions may appear minor within the complexity of a building project. Experienced repeatedly over months or years, they become a significant part of someone's working environment.
Design decisions are only part of the picture. Management policies determine whether employees can sit during a shift, adjust their clothing in response to temperature, take adequate breaks, or access certain facilities. A well-designed space may still fail to support workers if operational rules prevent them from using it comfortably. Conversely, relatively modest policy changes can sometimes improve working conditions without requiring substantial physical alterations.
This suggests that evaluating the human performance of buildings requires looking at design and operations together. The experience of a space is shaped as much by how it is managed as by how it was originally constructed.
Resilience Depends on People
Climate resilience has become an increasingly important consideration in building design and management. Emergency power, flood protection, backup systems, and continuity plans are essential for protecting assets and maintaining operations during severe weather events. But these systems often depend on people being available to monitor equipment, respond to residents, coordinate services, and manage unexpected situations.
The needs of those workers should therefore be part of resilience planning. If essential personnel are expected to remain on site during an extended emergency, the building's preparedness should account for adequate rest facilities, food, sanitation, safe working conditions, and appropriate staffing arrangements. These requirements cannot be addressed through technical infrastructure alone.
There is also an important distinction between the responsibilities of building management and the limitations of the physical environment. A management team may make considerable efforts to support employees during an emergency while working within the constraints of an older building that was never designed to accommodate extended staff stays. Understanding those constraints can inform future renovations, operational procedures, and decisions about emergency preparedness.
A resilient building is one in which the people responsible for maintaining essential services have the resources and conditions necessary to carry out their work safely. Planning for their needs strengthens the building's ability to respond to disruptions while recognizing the responsibilities and demands placed on its workforce.
The Knowledge Already Inside the Building
Building owners and design teams have access to increasingly sophisticated tools for understanding how spaces perform. Energy monitoring systems, maintenance records, occupant surveys, and post-occupancy evaluations provide valuable information about the operational and environmental conditions of a property.
Yet some of the most useful information about a building may come from people whose work brings them into contact with its spaces and systems every day.
Security personnel observe how people move through entrances, lobbies, and shared areas. Cleaning teams understand which materials are difficult to maintain and which spaces create unnecessary physical demands. Maintenance workers recognize recurring equipment problems, access limitations, and conditions that complicate repairs. These observations represent a form of practical knowledge developed through repeated experience, often over many years.
Much of this knowledge may remain within individual teams or informal conversations rather than finding its way into design reviews, capital improvement plans, or operational decision-making. The challenge is not necessarily a lack of information, but the absence of consistent ways to gather and use it.
Involving operational staff in relevant planning and evaluation processes can help address this gap. During renovations, their experience can inform decisions about material selection, circulation, maintenance access, and staff facilities. In existing buildings, structured opportunities for feedback can help management identify recurring issues and prioritize improvements. Their participation should be treated as a contribution of professional knowledge, with appropriate consideration for their time, responsibilities, and ability to raise concerns without negative consequences.
The value lies in ensuring that their observations can influence decisions, rather than simply collecting another set of opinions.
A More Complete Understanding of Building Performance
The built environment has made considerable progress in measuring energy efficiency, environmental quality, and the experience of building occupants. Expanding that attention to the people who operate and maintain buildings is a logical next step.
This does not require every project to develop an entirely new assessment framework. Existing design reviews, workplace policies, maintenance planning, and post-occupancy evaluations can provide opportunities to consider employee experiences more systematically. Questions about access to rest facilities, thermal comfort, occupational health, operational demands, and opportunities for worker input can become part of the information used to evaluate building performance.
There are practical reasons for doing so. Better-informed design and management decisions may help reduce avoidable operational difficulties, identify safety concerns, and improve the everyday experience of employees and occupants. Just as importantly, the people responsible for maintaining a building deserve working environments that support their own health, dignity, and well-being, independent of the benefits their working conditions may bring to an owner or employer.
A building's social impact cannot be understood solely through the experience of its residents, tenants, or visitors. It also includes the people whose work makes those experiences possible, the conditions under which they perform that work, and the extent to which their knowledge informs decisions about the spaces they maintain.
Looking at buildings from the perspective of the people who operate them offers an opportunity to recognize aspects of performance that conventional assessments may overlook. By incorporating these perspectives into design, management, and evaluation, organizations can make more informed decisions about how their buildings serve everyone connected to them.
This article accompanies a conversation with Stephen Bruno, author of Building Material: The Memoir of a Park Avenue Doorman, on Changing Tomorrow. The episode explores writing, work, relationships, and the experience of buildings from the perspective of someone who has spent more than 15 years working in New York residential real estate.
Listen to the conversation:
Read Stephen Bruno's book: Building Material: The Memoir of a Park Avenue Doorman